At night, or when there is fog or heavy rain, technology can help to dramatically upgrade our vison and enable us to see things that would otherwise be hidden.
Radio Detection and Ranging, or radar, has been around since the Second World War and is often credited with helping to win the Battle of Britain. This technology, even in its primitive form, enabled British fighter planes to accurately intercept incoming German bombers at night.
Since those early days the technology has developed hugely, and compact digital radar systems are now readily available and priced to suit even moderate-sized trailer boats and yachts.
Large commercial radar units, and larger recreational ones, are characterised by a horizontal antenna (called an open array) which spins slowly around. This transmits a strong pulse of electromagnetic energy, which then bounces off objects in the distance. By knowing the exact angle of the rotating beam and measuring the length of time for the echo to come back, the software can build up a picture of the surrounding area. The strength of the returning signal gives an indication of the size of the object and builds up a fairly accurate picture of distant objects.
One of the issues with radar has always been that large rotating antenna; another the relatively high energy output of traditional systems. Since radar technology uses microwave radiation, just like microwave ovens, much has been said about the risks of exposure to that energy. However, while it is still not a good idea to stand in front of a large commercial radar unit, modern units only transmit incredibly short pulses of radiation and pose no threat to humans.
Those in the industry joke that you are more at risk of being hit in the head from a spinning open-array antenna than suffering ill effects from the energy coming from it. And most recreational units mitigate even that risk by using a smaller antenna inside a completely enclosed cylindrical housing called a radome.
So, given that you probably already have a compatible multi-function display (MFD) on your boat, as discussed last issue, what are the considerations when looking to add a radar? Prices start from just over $2000 (assuming you have an MFD), but there are a bewildering number of options.
Even if you stick with just one manufacturer you will notice numerous models, each with different acronyms, specifications and prices. At the time of writing we counted no less than 40 different models from the four major marine electronics suppliers, all aimed at the recreational section. To confuse matters further, different manufacturers often use their own proprietary name for the same feature. Let’s try and make some sense of this.
The first decision to make is around the base technology, and the difference largely depends on the range you require. Traditional ‘pulse’ radar uses a high-powered magnetron to generate a very short duration burst of energy. These units transmit at high power outputs, typically 4kW to 25kW in recreational models, and have a range close to 100 nautical miles. For maximum range, a pulsed unit is the best option.
New solid-state technology uses a different technique called FMCW (Frequency Modulated Continuous Wave). This ‘broadband’ radar sends a continuous signal wave (rather than a pulse) with an increasing frequency (hence called broadband) and is roughly similar to the CHIRP used in sonar. That wave travels out, retaining its frequency and bouncing back from any object.
At the same time the system continues to output a wave at an increasing frequency. Some clever electronics compares the difference between the returning frequency and that currently being transmitted and calculates the precise distance to the target. Since this happens continuously over different frequencies throughout its range, a broadband system provides far better target detection and differentiation than a pulse radar.
Broadband units also transmit at far lower energy levels, making them safer for smaller boats. Naturally they also draw considerably less power, making them suitable for smaller
runabouts or sailboats with limited power. The downside is they have limited range. Earlier models had very poor performance outside the three-mile range, but new models, notably the 3G and 4G models from Navico, now have an effective range of up to 36 nautical miles.
And then, just to confuse things further, there is another new technology called pulse compression radar, offered in different variants by Simrad, Raymarine, Furuno and Garmin. Basically a hybrid between traditional pulse and CHIRP technologies, this provides lower-emission signals than a standard pulse but which produces excellent range and target resolution. This technology is also superior at detecting small moving targets, like a flock of flying birds and fast-moving runabouts. As such, it is best suited to medium range, with options of 24 to 72 nautical miles maximum range.
So, having chosen the base technology you want, the next decision is whether to go radome or open array. The radome encloses all the moving parts inside a composite housing, leaving nothing to snag on rigging, fishing lines or sails.
Some manufacturers offer equivalent models in both radome and open array configurations, but generally open arrays are larger and therefore have a higher output and greater range. Broadband units are generally radome, and pulse units may only be available as open arrays, but it is in that mid-range where the difficult decision comes. Note that the effective range is also affected by how high the antenna can be mounted above the water, with more height giving greater range.
Apart from the maximum range, the minimum distance is also an important aspect when deciding on a model, and units vary in this regard from as little as 10 metres to more than 100m. Boaties who have travelled out of Havelock in the Marlborough Sounds on a foggy morning will know how crucial this distance is, since the navigable channel is only 20 metres wide and it is a hairraising experience to hear another boat close by when you cannot see more than a few meters ahead of you. Virtually every boat operating out of that harbour has a radar installed.
The software supporting the radar signal is equally important, and of course this depends on what MFD or dedicated display you connect your antenna to. Most MFDs allow you to display the radar either in its own section of the screen or overlaid directly onto the marine chart, and some will integrate AIS signals to identify vessels which the radar detects.
If your MFD does not support your desired radar unit, you can opt to add a dedicated display with specific features for your chosen model.
Another useful option is MARPA (Mini-automatic Radar Plotting Aid) Target Tracking, a collision-avoidance software feature supported by some models. This enables the display to identify and track other vessels, showing their speed and bearing, warning of closest point of approach and the time to the closest point of approach.
This can be combined with proximity alarms to sound a warning if a vessel is too close and heading for a collision. This feature would be important to vessels operating in busy shipping lanes, such as cruising boats and large commercial vessels.
A variation on this is a feature displaying an echo trail which shows where the radar target has been, so you can easily see the direction it is moving and work out what the risk is to yourself.
So, knowing all this, how do you decide what unit to buy? A few fundamental questions should reduce the options considerably, leaving the final decision down to personal preference and budget:
If you are integrating to an existing multi-function display, then naturally start with the same manufacturer and look at what models are compatible. However, avoid limiting yourself too early, as you may find that the feature you really want requires a new MFD, possibly even a different brand.
Next decide on the maximum range you require, based on your typical usage. For recreational fisherman, 24nm (so, one of the broadband models) is most likely adequate. For passage-making sailing boats a greater range may be vital. This is where the greatest cost trade-off comes – generally, the greater the range, the higher the cost.
Next, check how much power is available on your vessel. A high-power pulse radar will quickly suck the battery dry on a yacht that does not have an engine continuously charging it, while a broadband unit will draw a fraction of the amount of current.
Do you need close-range capability? If your boating region regularly experiences fog then this may be more important to you than the maximum range. Also, if you often go into busy anchorages at night, then the close-range target resolution capabilities may be the most important feature.
For game fisherman, the ability to identify a flock of birds flying far enough away to be out of sight would be an extremely valuable feature. In that case look for a unit offering ‘Bird mode’ or similar.
Which radar?
SHARE:
Related Articles
Comments
This conversation is moderated by Boating New Zealand. Subscribe to view comments and join the conversation. Choose your plan →
This conversation is moderated by Boating New Zealand.
More from Boating New Zealand
International SailGP teams pus...
White Pointer boats celebrates...
NZ Antique & Classic Boat...
Close calls, a capsize and a c...
New Zealand’s SailGP Cha...
Historic boat sinks in D’Entre...
GET
STARLINK
HERE
NZ Events Worth Adding to Your Calendar
Have an event you'd like to list on Boating New Zealand. Contact us with the details.
Catch all the action of the Vendée Globe Race, starting 10 Nov, 2024 in Barcelona, Spain. Follow along with excitement at Boating New Zealand.
FISHING
Stabicraft Fish N Chicks Tournament, 6 - 8 Feb 2025 in Tauranga. Dress up theme is “Ladies of their Time”. Raising funds to help find a cure for Breast Cancer.
Surtees Annual Fishing Competition, 28 Feb - 1 Mar 2025 in Whakatane
Hook Me Up Fishing Competition - Matakana vs Hillside, 7 Mar 2025 in Whakatane
The Kubota Billfish Classic, 12 - 15 Mar 2025 in Mercury Bay, Whitianga
ITM Fishing Competition, 13 - 16 Mar 2025 in Whangaroa
NZ Lure Masters (Catch, Measure and Release competition), 3 & 4 Oct 2025, New Zealand wide
Stabicraft Te Anau Manapouri Fishing Classic, 25 - 27 Oct 2025 TBC in Te Anau Manapouri
REGATTAS
New Zealand Sail Grand Prix, 8 & 9 Feb 2025 in Sydney
Toyota Youth International Match Racing Cup, 26 Feb - 4 Mar 2025 in Auckland
PIC Harbour Classic, 28 Feb - 1 Mar 2025 in Auckland
Sydney to Auckland Ocean Race 2025, starting 11 Oct 2025 TBC from Sydney Harbour
PIC Insurance Brokers Coastal Classic, 24 Oct 2025 TBC from Auckland to Russell
Rolex Sydney to Hobart, 26 Dec 2025 starts in Sydney, Australia
Bay of Islands Sailing Week, end of Jan 2026 at Bay of Islands
NZ Millenium Cup, Feb 2025 at Waitemata Harbour
HYDRO THUNDER
JET BOAT RACING
UIM World Jetsprint Championships, 25 Jan -2 Feb 2025 at Wanaka (25 & 26 Jan) and Wanganui (1 & 2 Feb)
2025 NZ Marathon Coast-to-Coast, 16 to 25 Mar 2025 starting at Greymouth ad finishing at Christchurch
2024 Golden Homes NZ Jet Boat Marathon, 2025 dates TBC on Southland Rivers (Oreti, Waiau and Mataura)
National Jet Boat Rally 2024, 2025 date TBC at Oliver Road, Bendigo (near Cromwell)
WATERSPORTS
Yamaha Rollo's Marine Bridge 2 Bridge, 2025 dates tbc Staged on the Waikato River between Cambridge & Taupiri, based in Hamilton, New Zealand
ANTIQUE, CLASSIC & RETRO BOATS
25th NZ Antique & Classic Boat Show , 1 & 2 Mar 2025 at Lake Rotoiti, Nelson Lakes
SHOWS
Moana Auckland - New Zealand's Ocean Festival, 27 Jan to 9 Mar 2025 in Auckland
Auckland Boat Show, 6 - 9 Mar 2025 to be held at the Viaduct Events Centre and Jellicoe Harbour, Auckland
The Hutchwilco New Zealand Boat Show, 15-18 May 2025 to be held at the Viaduct Events Centre and Jellicoe Harbour, Auckland
NZ Boat, Fish and Dive Show, 30 & 31 Aug 2025 to be held at Mystery Creek Events Centre, Waipa
Houston Boat Show, 29 Jan - 2 Feb 2025 to be held at the NRG Center, Houston, Texas
International Boat Shows
COMING EVENTS
Dubai International Boat Show, 19 - 23 Feb 2025 to be held at the Dubai Harbour
Miami International Boat Show, 12 - 16 Feb 2025 to be held in Miami
Palm Beach International Boat Show, 19 - 23 Mar 2025 to be held along Flagler Drive in downtown West Palm Beach
International Multihull Show, 23 - 27 Apr 2025 to be held in Terre-plein Ouest du port La Grande-Motte (34), France
Palma International Boat Show, 30 Apr - 3 May 2025 to be held at the Superyacht Village, Palma, Spain
Barcaly's Jersey Boat Show, 3 - 5 May 2025 to be held in the Channel Islands
South Coast & Green Tech Boat Show, 9 - 11 May 2025 to be held in Ocean Village Marina, Southampton, Hampshire
The British Motor Yacht Show, 15 - 18 May 2025 to be held at the Swanwick Marina, Southampton, Hampshire
The Hutchwilco New Zealand Boat Show, 15 - 18 May 2025 at Auckland Showgrounds, Auckland
Sanctuary Cove International Boat show, 22 - 25 May 2025 to be held in Sanctuary Cove, Queensland
Sydney International Boat show, 31 July - 3 Aug 2025 to be held at ICC Sydney & Cockle Bay, Darling Harbour
Hiswa Te Water, 3 - 7 Nov 2025 to be held in Bataviahaven Lelystad, The Netherlands
Southampton International Boat Show, 19 - 28 Sep 2025 to be held in Southampton, UK
International BoatBuilders’ Exhibition & Conference (IBEX), 7 - 9 Oct 2025 to be held in Tampa, Florida
Annapolis Sail Boat Show, 9 - 13 Oct 2025 to be held at City Dock, Annapolis, Maryland
Newport International Boat Show, 20 - 23 Nov 2025 to be held in Newport, Rhode Island
Cannes Yachting Festival, 9 - 14 Sep 2025 at Cannes – Vieux Port & Port Canto
Genoa Boat Show, 18 - 23 Sep 2025 to be held in Genoa, Italy
Melbourne International Boat Show, Oct 2025, TBC to be held at New Quay Promenade Harbour Esplanade Seven Marinas
Biograd Boat Show, Oct 2025, TBC to be held in the City of Biograd, Croatia
Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show 29 Oct – 2 Nov 2025 to be held at several locations in Fort Lauderdale
METSTRADE 18 - 20 Nov 2025 to be held at the Rai, Amsterdam
Antigua Charter Yacht Show 4 - 9 Dec 2025 to be held at the Nelson's Dockyard UNESCO World Heritage Site, Antigua
Boot Düsseldorf 17 - 25 Jan 2026 to be held in Düsseldorf, Germany
New York Boat Show, Jan 2026 to be held at the Javits Center, New York
Bahamas Charter Yacht Show, Jan - Feb 2026 to be held at Nassau, Bahamas
Monaco Yacht Show, 24 - 27 Sep 2025 on Monacco