Boating New Zealand Boat Reviews
Reviews
Boating New Zealand News
News
Boating New Zealand Sports
Sport
Boating New Zealand Lifestyle
Lifestyle
BOAT-REVIEWS-MOBILE
Boat Reviews
BOAT-NEWS-MOBILE
News
BOAT-SPORTS-MOBILE
Sports
BOAT-LIFESTYLE-MOBILE
Lifestyle
HomeMagazineFeaturesEXISTENCE DOUBTFUL

EXISTENCE DOUBTFUL

Published
Bookmark post
Bookmarked
Bookmark post
Bookmarked

Picking your way around tropical reefs can be tricky at the best of times – but things get really awkward when your chart suggests you are near a hazard that might – or might not – actually exist. Story by Matt Vance.

On the old Admiralty Chart that lay unfolded on Manaroa III’s navigation table was a dotted oval with the words Sandy Island (1876). This simple note was punctuated with the letters E.D.

It lay among the clutter of nearby reefs, the usual soundings of deep open ocean – and a small tea stain that had absorbed into the fine paper – and which now looked like a phantom reef in the Coral Sea.

The letters stand for Existence Doubtful and how they got on the Admiralty Chart is a case of the power of authority over simple observation. Sandy islets and breakers were first sighted in the vicinity by the whaling ship Velocity in 1876. It was in an area near Bampton Reefs known for its atolls and low-lying islands.

- Advertisement -

Whether the crew of the Velocity saw a rip, a volcanic discolouration of the water – or were just in the wrong location – we will never know, but the island, as a dotted oval shape, was recorded and posted in notices to mariners. A few years later Sandy Island got a mention in an Australian Naval Directory and in 1908 its inclusion on the British Admiralty Chart lent the island even more legitimacy.

The British Admiralty spent much time, money and risk sending out voyagers to identify the many chart observations that had these dotted lines. Not knowing the detail of a world that the British Empire dominated with its ships was an annoying embarrassment.

The officers of Her Majesty’s ships were charged with hunting down the anomalies so that they could be scratched from the hallowed charts. In 1875 the Admiralty Charts were revised, based on a concerted effort to track down and discard 123 islands that did not exist.

The dotted lines of these islands had the letters E.D. printed beside them. Why the Admiralty never got to Sandy Island to confirm its existence and remove the doubt remains a mystery.

For sailors, even the faintest speck of land means danger so it is always being searched for and guarded against. Such is this sailorly respect for the land that once it had made it to the Admiralty Chart it had the momentum of authority which would carry it well into the 21st century.

Other forms of authority followed in step with the Admiralty when the National Geographic Society and The Times both included it in their maps of the Coral Sea.

By the time Google Earth came into being its sophisticated satellite imaging technology (mixed with a composite of existing charts and maps) was able to locate and include Sandy Island on its comprehensive coverage of the entire planet.

Strangely enough in 1982 the French survey of the waters around New Caledonia and the Coral Sea did not include the island. The Russian chart of the area completed in 1967 also seemed to overlook the island, yet the 2010 Michelin Map of the World included it.

Cracks were beginning to appear in the one thing most cultures view as a solid certainty – and that is land.

In 2012 the Australian survey vessel R/V Southern Surveyor stationed in the Coral Sea was engaged in a plate tectonic survey when one of the officers noticed a discrepancy between charts. Sandy Island was recorded on one of the charts but not on the others. Being in the vicinity of the island, the Captain decided to investigate. The Southern Surveyor arrived at the coordinates for Sandy Island and found nothing but ocean with the depth sounder reading over 1400m of water. Sandy Island had been officially undiscovered.

In the more than 136 years since it was first reported, Sandy Island had been given all the credence of a terra firma. Perhaps because we invest so much of our identity in islands, the ones that disappear through violent eruption or bombing are very disconcerting. The ones that disappear because they never existed are even more disconcerting and strike at our arrogance in believing nothing has escaped the laser vision of colonisation and technology.

Only a small minority of sailors read Admiralty Charts and an even smaller minority of ships’ officers ever read the Notices to Mariners. Sandy Island’s embarrassing disappearance could have been pulled off while everyone looked the other way, had it not been for the absolute trust mainstream society puts in technology.

On Google Earth, Sandy Island appeared as an oval island 15 miles long and three miles wide. It looked like a great place for a mid-ocean picnic or an overnight camp under the shimmering tropical stars. This giant of a corporation and purveyor of geographic truth had placed it there presumably because the Admiralty Chart said it was there, but on 26 November 2012 Google Earth deleted Sandy Island and patched the hole with a generic sea pattern.

When a void is created in a landscape it is immediately filled with our imagination. In the old version of Google Earth I have on my computer the position of the island is crowded with images of the fantasies that people have projected onto the place. Most of these fantasies involve paradise and it seems some involve dinosaurs and UFOs. Like mourners at a funeral, they turn up too late hoping to communicate their heart’s desire to the departed.

We live with the expectation that the world is fully visible and everything is known yet it seems we need islands that allow our thoughts to roam unimpeded like a tea stain on a chart and against the all-seeing eye of Google and the British Admiralty.

SHARE:

Related Articles

Previous article
Next article

Comments

This conversation is moderated by Boating New Zealand. Subscribe to view comments and join the conversation. Choose your plan →

This conversation is moderated by Boating New Zealand.

Boating New Zealand
Boating New Zealandhttps://www.boatingnz.co.nz
Boating NZ is New Zealand’s premier marine title devoted to putting its readers behind the wheel of the latest trailerboats, yachts and launches to hit the market. It inspires with practical content and cruising adventures, leads the fleet with its racing coverage and is on the pulse of the latest maritime news and innovation.

More from Boating New Zealand

Miami to host thrilling finale...

In an exciting announcement that underscores the rising prominence of elect...
E1 GP

Vendée round the globel LIVE! ...

Catch up with all the action from the past 24 hours in this 30-minute daily...
Vendee Globe - Round The World Yacht RaceVendée round the globe LIVE!

Dalin Reaches Pacific Mileston...

The Vendée Globe’s Pacific leg marks a significant milestone for the fleet,...
News

Charlie Dalin Leads Vendée Glo...

The Vendée Globe fleet has reached another significant milestone, with lead...
Race Day ReportsVendee Globe - Round The World Yacht Race

The Waterjet World Grand Prix ...

The Waterjet World Grand Prix (WGP) 2024 is heating up as it heads toward i...
Jetski World Championships

Kaikōura pāua poachers caught,...

In a significant enforcement action this week, Fisheries New Zealand office...
Marine ConservationNews
-- ADVERTISEMENT --

Follow Us

Weekly Newsletter

Stay up to date with the latest developments shaping New Zealand's Boating world.

Social Media

Follow us on social media to stay in the loop with the latest trends and news shaping New Zealand's boating scene!

-- THINGS WE LOVE --

GET
STARLINK
HERE

-- DIRECTORY LISTING --

NZ Events Worth Adding to Your Calendar

Have an event you'd like to list on Boating New Zealand. Contact us with the details.

Catch all the action of the Vendée Globe Race, starting 10 Nov, 2024 in Barcelona, Spain. Follow along with excitement at Boating New Zealand.

FISHING

Makaira Trailer Boat Competition, 25 & 26 Jan 2025 in Whangaroa

NZ Lure Masters (Catch, Measure and Release competition), 3 & 4 Oct 2025, New Zealand wide

Stabicraft Te Anau Manapouri Fishing Classic, 25 - 27 Oct 2025 TBC in Te Anau Manapouri

REGATTAS

Rolex Sydney to Hobart, 26 Dec 2024 starts in Sydney, Australia

New Zealand Sail Grand Prix, 18 & 19 Jan 2025 in Auckland

Bay of Islands Sailing Week, 21 - 24 Jan 2025 at Bay of Islands

NZ Millenium Cup, 1 - 4 Feb 2025 at Waitemata Harbour

Toyota Youth International Match Racing Cup, 26 Feb - 4 Mar 2025 in Auckland

PIC Harbour Classic, 28 Feb - 1 Mar 2025 in Auckland

Sydney to Auckland Ocean Race 2025, starting 11 Oct 2025 TBC from Sydney Harbour

PIC Insurance Brokers Coastal Classic, 24 Oct 2025 TBC from Auckland to Russell

NZ Match Racing Championships, 2025 dates tbc in Auckland

HYDRO THUNDER

Lucas Oil Hydro Thunder Race - Mangakino, 18 & 19 Jan 2025 at Mangakino

Lucas Oil Hydro Thunder Race - Karapiro, 7 - 9 Feb 2025 at Karapiro

Lucas Oil Hydro Thunder Race - Lake Rotoiti, 8 - 9 Mar 2025 at Nelson Lakes

Lucas Oil Hydro Thunder Race - Lake Twizel, 29 - 30 Mar 2025 at Twizel

JET BOAT RACING

2024/25 NZ Jetsprint Championship R2, 1 Dec 2024 at Featherston

2024/25 NZ Jetsprint Championship R3, 27 Dec 2024 at Wanganui

UIM World Jetsprint Championships, 25 Jan -2 Feb 2025 at Wanaka (25 & 26 Jan) and Wanganui (1 & 2 Feb)

2024/25 NZ Jetsprint Championship R4, 23 Feb 2025 at Wanganui

2025 NZ Marathon Coast-to-Coast, 16 to 25 Mar 2025 starting at Greymouth ad finishing at Christchurch

2024 Golden Homes NZ Jet Boat Marathon, 2025 dates TBC on Southland Rivers (Oreti, Waiau and Mataura)

National Jet Boat Rally 2024, 2025 date TBC at Oliver Road, Bendigo (near Cromwell)

WATERSPORTS

Yamaha Rollo's Marine Bridge 2 Bridge, 2025 dates tbc Staged on the Waikato River between Cambridge & Taupiri, based in Hamilton, New Zealand

NON-MOTORISED SPORT

Waka Ama - 2025 National Sprint Championships, 12 - 18 Jan 2025 at Lake Karapiro, Cambridge

Waka Ama - 2025 Secondary School Nationals, 24 - 28 Mar 2025 at Lake Tikitapu, Rotorua

ANTIQUE, CLASSIC & RETRO BOATS

25th NZ Antique & Classic Boat Show , 1 & 2 Mar 2025 at Lake Rotoiti, Nelson Lakes

SHOWS

Moana Auckland - New Zealand's Ocean Festival, 27 Jan to 9 Mar 2025 in Auckland

Auckland Boat Show, 6 - 9 Mar 2025 to be held at the Viaduct Events Centre and Jellicoe Harbour, Auckland

The Hutchwilco New Zealand Boat Show, 15-18 May 2025 to be held at the Viaduct Events Centre and Jellicoe Harbour, Auckland

-- DIRECTORY LISTING --

International Boat Shows

COMING EVENTS

Antigua Charter Yacht Show 4 - 9 Dec 2024 to be held at the Nelson's Dockyard UNESCO World Heritage Site, Antigua

Boot Düsseldorf 18 - 26 Jan 2025 to be held in Düsseldorf, Germany

New York Boat Show, 22 - 26 Jan 2025 to be held at the Javits Center, New York

Bahamas Charter Yacht Show, 29 Jan - 2 Feb 2025 to be held at Nassau, Bahamas

Houston Boat Show, 29 Jan - 2 Feb 2025 to be held at the NRG Center, Houston, Texas

Dubai International Boat Show, 19 - 23 Feb 2025 to be held at the Dubai Harbour

Miami International Boat Show, 12 - 16 Feb 2025 to be held in Miami

Palm Beach International Boat Show, 19 - 23 Mar 2025 to be held along Flagler Drive in downtown West Palm Beach

International Multihull Show, 23 - 27 Apr 2025 to be held in Terre-plein Ouest du port La Grande-Motte (34), France

Palma International Boat Show, 30 Apr - 3 May 2025 to be held at the Superyacht Village, Palma, Spain

Barcaly's Jersey Boat Show, 3 - 5 May 2025 to be held in the Channel Islands

South Coast & Green Tech Boat Show, 9 - 11 May 2025 to be held in Ocean Village Marina, Southampton, Hampshire

The British Motor Yacht Show, 15 - 18 May 2025 to be held at the Swanwick Marina, Southampton, Hampshire

The Hutchwilco New Zealand Boat Show, 15 - 18 May 2025 at Auckland Showgrounds, Auckland

Sanctuary Cove International Boat show, 22 - 25 May 2025 to be held in Sanctuary Cove, Queensland

Sydney International Boat show, 31 July - 3 Aug 2025 to be held at ICC Sydney & Cockle Bay, Darling Harbour

Hiswa Te Water, 3 - 7 Nov 2025 to be held in Bataviahaven Lelystad, The Netherlands

Southampton International Boat Show, 19 - 28 Sep 2025 to be held in Southampton, UK

International BoatBuilders’ Exhibition & Conference (IBEX), 7 - 9 Oct 2025 to be held in Tampa, Florida

Annapolis Sail Boat Show, 9 - 13 Oct 2025 to be held at City Dock, Annapolis, Maryland

Newport International Boat Show, 20 - 23 Nov 2025 to be held in Newport, Rhode Island

Cannes Yachting Festival, 9 - 14 Sep 2025 at Cannes – Vieux Port & Port Canto

Genoa Boat Show, 18 - 23 Sep 2025 to be held in Genoa, Italy

Melbourne International Boat Show, Oct 2025, TBC to be held at New Quay Promenade Harbour Esplanade Seven Marinas

Biograd Boat Show, Oct 2025, TBC to be held in the City of Biograd, Croatia

Fort Lauderdale International Boat Show 29 Oct – 2 Nov 2025 to be held at several locations in Fort Lauderdale

METSTRADE 18 - 20 Nov 2025 to be held at the Rai, Amsterdam

Monaco Yacht Show, 24 - 27 Sep 2025 on Monacco