Boating New Zealand Boat Reviews
Reviews
Boating New Zealand News
News
Boating New Zealand Sports
Sport
Boating New Zealand Lifestyle
Lifestyle

or LOG IN

AC37-2024

AC37

BOAT-REVIEWS

Boat Reviews

BOAT-NEWS

News

BOAT-SPORT

Sports

BOAT-LIFESTYLE

Lifestyle

BOAT-REVIEWS-MOBILE
Boat Reviews
BOAT-NEWS-MOBILE
News
BOAT-SPORTS-MOBILE
Sports
BOAT-LIFESTYLE-MOBILE
Lifestyle

Win or lose?

Bookmark post
Bookmarked
Bookmark post
Bookmarked

It is with mixed feelings that I contemplate recently announced plans to introduce 19 new marine protection areas inside the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park.

Not because the Gulf doesn’t need to protect and restore marine habitats and ecosystems – it does, and action on this front has been too long in coming – but because I believe recreational fishers, of which I am one, will be disproportionately penalised if the Hauraki Gulf/Tīkapa Moana Marine Protection Bill is passed as proposed.

The new protections include extensions to two existing marine reserves at Cathedral Cove and Goat Island, the creation of 12 High Protection Areas (HPAs) – no-take areas where fishing or food gathering is prohibited – and five seafloor protection areas (SPAs), where commercial and recreational fishing will be allowed provided there is no bottom contact.

In total, including Cable Zones, about 18% of the Gulf will be protected. Authorised customary fishing and harvesting of seafood will be allowed in high protection areas.

Marine protection areas will affect me personally, along with many thousands of others who love to fish and dive the waters of the Hauraki Gulf. I’m mostly a small boat fisher, restricted to inshore areas. So I’m disappointed to note that several of my favourite fishing spots will be swallowed by new HPAs. The same will doubtless be true for thousands of other recreational fishers.

Then there are the charter boats that take recreational fishers further out into the Gulf to places like the Mokohinau Islands, Aldermen Islands, Cape Jackson and Channel Island – even Little Barrier Island – all of which fall wholly or partly inside HPAs. What will become of those businesses?

But I’m willing to take one for the team should the proposed protections give us a healthier, more diverse marine environment with more fish in the water. If that happens, we all benefit.

However, I’m concerned these new protections will only increase fishing pressure on the rest of the Gulf. And that they neither properly address bigger issues like commercial fishing, including bottom trawling (which will continue inside the Marine Park) and pilchard seining (removing a main food source for fish, birds and marine mammals), nor environmental damage from sedimentation and pollution arising from land-based activities. Meaningful controls on these activities would, in my opinion, offer far more effective protection for the Gulf than squeezing out recreational fishers.

Maybe I’m being selfish, but I would far rather see commercial fishing excluded from the Marine Park, along with stricter environmental controls for land-based developments, than lose my favourite fishing spots!

There will be another opportunity for the public to provide feedback during the Select Committee process on the Bill.

The Government hopes legislation and protection will be in place by mid 2024.

John Eichelsheim
Editor

   

SHARE:

Related Articles

Previous article
Next article

Comments

This conversation is moderated by Boating New Zealand. Subscribe to view comments and join the conversation. Choose your plan →

More from Boating New Zealand

Race 4: American Magic Triumph...

An Early Surge from the US The US team, under pressure to perform, burst...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Luna Rossa Confirm Star Billin...

It was another very tricky day in Barcelona with a sea-state of almost a me...
AC37NewsNews

Race 3: INEOS Britannia Crushe...

The Start: A Penalty Changes Everything The second race between th...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Race 2: American Magic Stuns L...

Wind Woes and Early Struggles The race began in fickle wind co...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Race 1: The Dream Continues Fo...

From the moment the race began, it was clear this would be no ordinary...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Race 2: Italy Dominate as UK a...

The race began under ominous skies, with slow winds adding an ext...
AC37SportsYAC Day 2

BOATING WEEKLY

Join Thousands of
New Zealand Boating Enthusiasts!

Exclusive deals, boat reviews, sports coverage, stories, and our best tips for NZ boaters ⏤ free and straight to your inbox.

HOT OFF THE PRESS

Race 4: American Magic Triumphs as Luna Rossa Suffers Heartbreaking Breakdown in Thrilling Race

An Early Surge from the US The US team, under pressure to perform, burst off the starting line wi...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Luna Rossa Confirm Star Billing In UniCredit Youth America’s Cup

It was another very tricky day in Barcelona with a sea-state of almost a metre and a shifting, patch...
AC37NewsNews

Race 3: INEOS Britannia Crushes Alinghi Red Bull Racing to Secure Final Spot in America’s Cup

The Start: A Penalty Changes Everything The second race between these two rivals today saw ...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Race 2: American Magic Stuns Luna Rossa in Chaotic Showdown to Keep America’s Cup Dream Alive

Wind Woes and Early Struggles The race began in fickle wind conditions, with both teams...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Race 1: The Dream Continues For Alinghi Red Bull Racing, winning over INEOS Bratannia

From the moment the race began, it was clear this would be no ordinary contest. The wind was bl...
AC37Louis Vuitton CupLVC Semi's Day 4

Events Worth Adding to Your Calendar

Have an event you'd like to list on Boating New Zealand. Contact us with the details.

COMING EVENTS

Catch all the action of the Louis Vuitton 37th America's Cup, happening from 22 Aug to 27 Oct 2024 in Barcelona, Spain. Follow along with excitement at Boating New Zealand.

The Outdoor Expo, 14 & 15 Sep 2024 at Canterbury Agricultural Park

NZ Boat, Fish & Dive Expo, 31 Aug & 1 Sep 2024 at Mystery Creek Events Centre, Hamilton

NZ Millenium Cup, 1-4 Feb 2025 at Bay of Islands

Auckland Boat Show, 6-9 March 2025 at Viaduct Events Centre and Jellicoe Harbour, Auckland

The Hutchwilco New Zealand Boat Show, 15-18 May 2025 at Auckland Showgrounds, Auckland

NEWS TIPS?
Send your photos, videos, stories, and tip-offs to ahoy@boatingnz.co.nz or call us on 022-023-7507.

ADVENTURES AT SEA

The Norwoods World Tour

When A Series Of Unfortunate Events Force An Unexpected U-Turn

Saturday a week ago we went to drop off a rental car we had hired to take my sister back to the airp...
One Family’s Boating Journey

One Family’s Boating Journey; That sinking feeling

What a shocking end to our summer! We never saw this plot twister coming!
One Family’s Boating Journey

One Family’s Boating Journey: Life lessons

As our two boys, Rafe and Chris, have discovered when you’re living onboard, life will throw you cur...
One Family’s Boating Journey

One Family’s Boating Journey; Racing to Whangamata

As we kissed our keel ever so slightly on the sandbar the pit of my stomach sank. Had our luck run o...
One Family’s Boating Journey

One Family’s Boating Journey: A bridge too far

The Woodham family’s quest to master safe anchoring continues – starting this time with Islington Ba...